Website for Savannah Agenda
This story also appeared in Savannah Agenda

Nov. 21, 2026 โ€“ Chatham County wants to block the nonprofit owners of the Bethesda Academy from annexing about 44 acres of forested land near Skidaway Island into the city of Savannah, contending that the annexation would create an โ€œillegal islandโ€ because the property is not contiguous to city limits as required by state law.

In a Nov. 13 lawsuit filed in Chatham County Superior Court, the county asked for a declaratory judgment and temporary restraining order preventing the city from moving forward with the petition until a judge rules on the legality of the annexation.

The proposed annexation includes two parcels, as outlined in the petition request sent by the property ownersโ€™ attorney Robert McCorkle in mid-September. The almost 44-acre Bethesda site is a triangle-shaped forested piece of land located west of Diamond Causeway and north of Ferguson Avenue, across from a Kroger-anchored shopping center. The second parcel is a residential piece of property owned by Michael and Sheila Koncul at 9503 Whitefield Ave., consisting of a narrow 3-acre strip extending out to the Vernon River.

The county is challenging the petitionerโ€™s contention that the Whitefield parcel is โ€œcontiguousโ€ to the city, claiming the city limits are separated by state-owned marshes and waterways. McCorkle did not respond to a request for comment sent on Nov. 16.

Bethesda Academyโ€™s nonprofit owner requested the annexation of an almost 43.83-acre undeveloped site at Diamond Causeway and Ferguson Avenue. Source: SAGIS.org
9503 Whitefield Avenue consists of narrow 3-acre strip extending to the Vernon River (highlighted in blue) that the petition claims is contiguous to city limits. Source: SAGIS.org

In an Oct. 1 notification to the county, Savannah Planning and Urban Design Director Bridget Lidy said the proposed annexation would cover about 47 acres and that the cityโ€™s initial zoning designation would be Planned Development. The Bethesda property is currently zoned Residential Agriculture with an environmental overlay under Chatham Countyโ€™s zoning ordinance.

In an Oct. 22 letter to Mayor Van Johnson, Chatham County Commission Chairman Chester Ellis said that the annexation also โ€œwill entail taking vacant land that has been traditionally used for an agricultural purpose and rezoning it to obtain an inappropriate intense mixed use of apartments, condominiums, single family homes, and undefined retail use.โ€

The county claims in the lawsuit that Bethesda is restricted from selling the property outright, and, as an alternative, the historic institution intends to enter a long-term ground lease with a developer, Atlantic Companies, for a mixed-use living space with a commercial component. Atlantic Companies did not respond to a request for comment made on Nov. 16.

Bethesda is seeking the annexation due to the commercial developerโ€™s need for water and sewer services to the proposed development, which the county claims the city will not provide, unless the property is annexed into city limits in order to become a paying customer of the city. However, the county contends that the city would be unable to provide other public services such as police, fire and garbage collection, since the โ€œcity islandโ€ would be located in a rural area surrounded on all sides by unincorporated county.

โ€œThe City is not able to provide services in the same manner that it can provide in other areas of the City,โ€ Ellis wrote.

The city did not respond to requests for comment sent on Nov. 16 and Nov. 20.

The Chatham County Commission voted to oppose the annexation after meeting behind closed doors in executive session on Oct. 16.

This story available through a partnership with Savannah Agenda, a newsroom covering government in Chatham County.

Eric Curl is a journalist and editor/owner of Savannah Agenda, an online news site dedicated to community engagement.