Capitol Beat News Service
This story also appeared in Capitol Beat News Service

ATLANTA โ€” A proposal for a quick switch to hand-marked paper ballots cleared the Georgia Senate on Friday, an idea that election officials say would disrupt this yearโ€™s elections.

The Senateโ€™s 32-21 party-line vote sets up a showdown over competing bills that would change Georgiaโ€™s voting system. The Senate bill would take effect this summer, while a House proposal would delay the transition until the 2028 election year.

The measure that advanced Friday would require voters to fill out ballots by bubbling in ovals instead of making their choices on touchscreens. Millions of ballots would need to be preprinted and stored until voters fill them out.

Immediately replacing Georgiaโ€™s statewide voting system would be โ€œirresponsible and unrealistic,โ€ said Joseph Kirk, president of the Georgia Association of Voter Registration and Election Officials.

โ€œItโ€™s just not enough timeโ€ for training, testing, and implementation, Kirk said. โ€œYou donโ€™t want to do it for the first time in a Georgia 2026 gubernatorial election, when weโ€™re going to have lines and have a bunch of folks there. Thatโ€™s a really heavy lift.โ€

The bill follows a state law legislators passed two years ago that set a deadline to remove computer QR codes from ballots by July 1 of this year. Critics of Georgiaโ€™s election system say voters canโ€™t read QR codes to verify that their ballots accurately reflect their choices.

The Houseโ€™s proposal would move that deadline until 2028, before voters decide on the next U.S. president.

Sen. Greg Dolezal, R-Cumming, said now is the time to change to hand-marked paper ballots.

Hand-marked ballots are the main election day voting method in two-thirds of the United States, according to the election technology organization Verified Voting.

โ€œDemocrats tell you on one hand we should move to paper ballots. But now that weโ€™re trying to do it, itโ€™s a threat to democracy: Bloody Sunday, voter suppression, Donald Trump,โ€ Dolezal said. โ€œAll that weโ€™re asking is for Georgians โ€ฆ to vote the way that the vast majority of people in America vote.โ€

Critics of Georgiaโ€™s elections, including election security advocates and Republicans disillusioned by Trumpโ€™s loss in 2020, say Georgiaโ€™s touchscreen voting system is untrustworthy and insecure.

But election officials and Democrats say Georgiaโ€™s elections are accurate, and allegations of widespread fraud have never been proved.

Sen. Kim Jackson, D-Stone Mountain, said the billโ€™s requirement to print so many ballots before elections introduces new problems.

โ€œWe have built in all kinds of opportunities for human error, let alone the major security risks and concerns that I have when you have thousands and thousands of preprinted ballots sitting in someoneโ€™s fellowship hall,โ€ Jackson said. โ€œGeorgia is moving in a direction of changing our system because there has been so much doubt seeded into our system, even though weโ€™ve proven that they are safe and secure.โ€

Under the competing bill in the House, the state would purchase new ballot-on-demand printers that would create ballots when voters arrive rather than require blank ballots in advance.

The Senate bill also includes new provisions that would fine county governments $100 for each voter registration they fail to cancel after receiving information those voters might have moved away, require election officials to post the names of all voters by midnight on election day, and mandate recounts by hand.

Senators previously voted down a similar version of their elections bill earlier this year, but Republicans mustered enough votes Friday to override Democratic opposition.

With just two business days left before this yearโ€™s legislative session ends, Georgia lawmakers will need to decide how to resolve their difference.

The House could consider the bill that passed the Senate on Friday, House Bill 960. Or the House could move forward with its legislation, Senate Bill 214, that would replace Georgiaโ€™s voting system before the 2028 election.

This story is available through a news partnership with Capitol Beat, an initiative of the Georgia Press Educational Foundation.

Mark Niesse is a veteran reporter with expertise in the Georgia legislature and voting laws.